Select Page

  Aloha Dreams

   Fabulous Recipes, Cooking for a Crowd & Dream Home Design      


Perfect Potato Salad for your Summer BBQ & Entertaining

Potato Salad

It’s almost SUMMER!!!  And I, for one, can’t wait. I’m ready for some potato salad.  Right now.  There are a lot of marginal potato salad recipes out there. You know the ones I’m talking about. The potatoes are waxy or undercooked, there isn’t enough creamy stuff to bind the whole thing together, the flavor or texture is too uniform, or – worst of all – the potatoes, which are supposed to be the star of the show, are bland and uninspiring.

Don’t get me wrong. I love potatoes.

Really love them.

If it’s got potatoes in it, I’m your girl!  But I’m often disappointed with potato salads.

This potato salad recipe is the culmination of many years of small improvements. I started with mom’s recipe (which was pretty great already) and modified it to include crunchy dill pickles for added zing. Next I switched out the new red potatoes for Yukon golds.  As you’re gently mixing the ingredients together some of the Yukon gold potatoes break down into a wonderful tangy mash.  That’s what gives it that great creaminess.

Potato Salad

Then I added some green onions for color and flavor.   It was very good, but something was still missing. Although their texture was perfect, the potatoes were still bland.

Finally, several years ago I found the secret.

The secret ingredient?   Pickle Juice.

Potato Salad

Yep. Pickle Juice. I picked up this trick from reading the Food Lab by J. Kenji Lopez-Alt over at Serious Eats, a fantastic site. He’s a wonderful cook and I’m consistently impressed with his recipes.

Along with all of the great ingredients that give this salad a wonderful depth of flavor and lots of texture, the pickle juice when mixed with the hot potatoes infuses them with a wonderful tang. Combined with the creamy texture created when some of the potatoes break down and mix with the mayonnaise, this potato salad is insanely special.

Potato Salad

This Potato Salad can, and should, be made in advance. In fact, it’s best served the next day. Or you can cover and refrigerate for at least 3 hours before serving.  I love to use one of our family’s old green or yellow Pyrex bowls.  As you can see from the pictures below, it’s been through A LOT of rounds of Potato Salad.  Do you have a favorite family serving bowl or dish?

Potato Salad

Pin for Later

Or Make Now.


Hungry Yet??

Me too.  Let’s get started!


Potato Salad
Prep Time
30 mins
Cook Time
5 mins
Total Time
35 mins

It might seem like a lot of salt in the water to boil the potatoes, but that, along with the pickle juice is what gives the potatoes more flavor.

Course: Side Dish
Cuisine: American
Servings: 18 people
Author: Betsy Edwards
  • 4.5 pounds Yukon Gold potatoes peeled and cut into 1/2-inch chunks, that’s about 10 – 11 med/large potatoes
  • 1 tablespoon salt
  • 5 tablespoons pickle juice
  • 1 tablespoon yellow mustard
  • 1 cup mayonnaise
  • 1 teaspoon salt
  • 3/4 red onion diced
  • 4 green onions chopped
  • 5 spears Kosher dill pickles cubed (not Polish)
  1. Measure dill pickle juice into a small bowl or measuring cup and set aside.

  2. Add potatoes and 1 tablespoon salt to 3 quarts water in a large saucepot. Bring to a boil over high heat. Once boiling, reduce heat to low and simmer until potatoes are tender when pierced with a knife, about 25 - 30 minutes.
  3. Meanwhile, in another bowl, combine mayonnaise, mustard, red onion, green onions, pickles and 1 teaspoon salt.
  4. When potatoes are tender, drain thoroughly and add hot potatoes to a large bowl. Sprinkle pickle juice over potatoes and stir gently to coat.

  5. Gently fold mayonnaise mixture into potatoes.
Make Ahead Note:
  1. Potato Salad can, and should, be made in advance. It’s best served the next day. Cover and refrigerate for at least 3 hours before serving. Leftovers can be stored, covered, in the refrigerator for up to 4 days.



Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Potato Salad for a Crowd

5 Reasons this is a Fantastic Large Group Potato Salad Recipe:

  1. It makes 5 pounds of potato salad.  This works out to 16 (5 ounce) servings or 20 (4 ounce servings).  If you are serving this as one of 4 or more items on a buffet, the average person will take a 4 ounce serving.
  2. It’s a great make in advance recipe.  In fact, it’s better the next day.
  3. It holds up well on a serving line.
  4. It’s very easy, it always turns out great and can be assigned out if you’re cooking in large quantities.  It’s far better than anything you can buy.
  5. Everyone loves it.
Potato Salad

Want more delicious recipes ?

Dutch Oven Peach Cobbler

This lovely summer dessert combines sweet juicy peaches with a crunchy, buttery, golden brown cobbler. I served this at our Young Men and Young Women Church Camp, but it’s just as perfect for your family’s summer dinner cooked in the oven!

Marvelous Meatball Sandwiches

Want a wonderful ooey-gooey, saucy, savory Freezer Meal Sandwich Recipe? These little meatballs are baked in the oven, heated with a great time-saving spaghetti sauce, and place on a crunchy hoagie roll slathered with garlic butter and melty Provolone cheese! And you have a Fan-‘freakin’-tastic sandwich (to quote Jeff).

Easy Oven Rice for a Crowd

Don’t miss this one! Now you can make perfect rice EVERY TIME in just 30 minutes with this easy and proven recipe to cook rice in the oven. You’ll want to add this to your recipe box for sure.

Butter Pecan French Toast Breakfast Casserole

Looking for an over-the-top delicious breakfast for your family this holiday season? This wonderful overnight Butter Pecan French Toast Casserole won’t fail to delight. Nestled in between the velvety pieces of cream-soaked bread are bits of buttery, suger-y crunchy pecans. Heaven!

Tater Tot Breakfast Casserole for a Crowd

You’ll love this Delicious Easy Make Ahead Breakfast Casserole. They don’t get any quicker or easier than this! The great thing about this dish is that it comes together easily in 20 minutes night before and is simply the best Breakfast Casserole I’ve ever had. It’s the perfect Breakfast Casserole for your Crowd this holiday season. I’ve also included a smaller version which serves 12.

I’m so excited you are making one of my recipes and I would love to see how it turns out!  Make sure to share the aloha on instagram and tag me@alohadreams so I can see your masterpiece!

Follow me on Instagram . Have fun cooking, and be happy!

Aloha Dreams

Welcome to Aloha Dreams!

I'm so glad you dropped by.  I'm Betsy.  Here you'll find my favorite fabulous, trusted recipes - everything from delicious, quick meals for your family to wonderful classics made easy.

I'm also here to help you with large group recipes from 20 to 200.  So next opportunity you get to cook for a large group - Say 'Yes!'  Then relax. I've got your back.

Ever wished you could build your dream home? How about building your dream home in a tropical paradise?  Join me, room by room, as we design and build a fabulous dream home in Hawaii!

Explore Aloha Dreams

Things to do Big Island of Hawaii
Dream Home Bathroom


If you're planning a vacation to Hawaii, I've got you covered on the very best places to go!   From many amazing restaurants to incredible adventures in the surf and on land, this is your go-to source for unique and exciting things to do on the Big Island of Hawaii.  Or just take a Virtual Vacation!!    Let's go!


If you've been asked to cook for a large group activity, be it a Girl's Camp or a Graduation Party, say Yes!  I'm here to help.  From Menus to Game Plans to Recipes, I'll help you keep on schedule and turn out amazingly delicious food if you're cooking for a crowd!  My recipes are tested and trusted.    Let's cook! 


Ever wished you could build your dream home?  Like amazing house design and home building ideas?  Me too!  Join me as I design and build a home on the Big Island of Hawaii. Follow along while I design each room. Enjoy a front row seat for the entire amazing construction process.  Let's play!


Would you like to throw a Luau, but not sure where to start?   Want to know how to build a tiki bar and roast a pig?  Here's everything you need to have a luau.  How about a Christmas Feast or even a fabulous dinner for your neighborhood supper club?  You've come to the right place.    Let's party!

Tropical Salad

Never miss a single Fabulous Recipe!

Sign UP today and ENJOY free Recipes & Party Ideas in your inbox.

(No spam - I promise!)

You have Successfully Subscribed!